Politics, Programming and Possibilities
3 Mar
A friend of mine, Paige Harris, recently had her laptop motherboard give up on her. She’s owned a Sony VAIO for a while and with its passing, she asked a few friends what they’d recommend as a replacement. Since I switched to a Mac a couple of years ago, I’ve been extremely pleased with the operating system and how it has directly benefited my work flow, so I recommended it to her with very few caveats.
Since I promised Paige that she’d be impressed with what Mac OS X could do for her, I thought it would be a nice idea to highlight some of my favorite features.
In Windows, the desktop is a static kind of place where clean-freaks keep nothing but a Recycle Bin, and the utterly unorganized keep everything (many enjoy this—I know).
Using Mac OS X, however, the desktop actually became a useful place for me to store related things that I was currently working on. Because of Exposé—a feature that, among other things, lets you swish all of your currently opened windows away to “expose” the desktop—I could access my relevant “current items” as I would on a real-life desk top.
Imagine the Windows alternative: you would have to drop what you’re doing, “minimize” all of your open windows to reveal the desktop, and then continue with your workflow.
One of my favorite features is the way that Mac OS X takes full advantage of the Drag and Drop concept. While it’s true that you can drag a thing or two in Windows, most switchers will be utterly amazed by what they were missing once they have a short training session.
For example, even some seasoned Mac users don’t know that the little “document icon” in all of their applications’ title bars is actually clickable and draggable! How’s that useful? Well, let’s say that you’re writing a Word document (OS X supports Microsoft Word for Mac). As you finish writing it, you realize you’d like to email it. How do you tell your Mail program, “Hey, just mail that thing I was working on 2 seconds ago”?
In Windows, I would open my Mail application, create a new mail window, click the ‘attach’ button, and then search my files and folders for the document I was just working on.
In Mac OS X however, things are very different. Instead, I click the “document icon” in the title bar, and drag it to Mail. BAM, I have a new mail message open with the file pasted in as an attachment. Same goes for pictures, videos, whatever.
Combine this drag-and-drop ease with the fact that you can “swish” your windows out of the way (by moving the mouse to the corner of the screen) to reveal the desktop, or shrink them all so you can move your focus to another window (again, using exposé) this is a killer workflow feature in my day-to-day use.
I remember when I was a kid, I used to use DOS for most of the games and programs I used. Installing new software was not necessarily obvious—whether you had to use the INSTALL.EXE program on the disk, or just copy things over was 50/50. But uninstalling was a dream: just delete the directory (folder) it was installed to!
Then I moved to Windows. Things started to get complicated. You couldn’t just copy things over from your friend’s computer anymore—that almost never worked. No, you had to have the original install disks or CD and use the install program. Why? Because the number of locations on your system that the new software was sent to was more than 1. Installing also meant that things like the Registry would have to be modified. In short, installing software on a Windows machine is messy—and that makes uninstalling worse. If you were lucky, either the software itself was shipped with an uninstaller, or the Windows system uninstaller was notified of the program and would provide some way to remove the software. On more than one occasion I resorted to formatting my hard drive and re-installing windows just to start with a clean system slate.
What’s different about OS X? Drag and drop to Applications to install. Drag and drop to the Trash to uninstall. The first time I did that I was like, “That’s it? Wow. Why can’t Windows be like that?”
Everyone knows how to use the Windows “Start” menu: click Start, go to Programs, choose a folder, slide your mouse, let go of the mouse button. How often have you used anything other than “Programs” in your start menu? In my case, aside from the occasional need to access the Control Panel, almost never.
In Mac OS X, you get a simple Dock—always visible and always open (unless you configure it to hide itself)—where all of your most common applications go. One click and your program opens.
The interesting thing here is that nothing goes in this “one-click” applications Dock unless you put it there. Psychologically, this helps me more than the Windows solution—that is, in Windows, your most commonly accessed applications magically get chosen by the OS to go in the Start menu’s direct access list. Rather, when I make a conscious choice to put something in the OS X Dock, I know exactly where I put it and that it’s not going to disappear by atrophy.
So is there anything I don’t like about a Mac? Well, yes. They aren’t show stoppers, but here are a few things I’ve experienced that I wouldn’t wish upon anyone else:
As you can tell, if you’ve read through the article to this point, I’m a sort of a fan. I wasn’t always thus. I used to think Linux was the coolest thing ever, and that I would never leave for a commercial alternative. But my switch to Mac OS has been two years old now, and I can’t imagine moving back. I don’t have much to say to deride Apple’s operating system. Conclusion: I’ve benefited from switching, and if they ask me, I tell all of my friends that they’ll like it too.
10 Responses for "Why I Recommend Mac OS X to Friends"
Hi Duane,
For item 1 in your list, Windows has the same (similar?) feature called Show Desktop. Not sure if it’s the same as the OSX feature that your are talking about, but with a single icon click on the task bar I can minimize every open application.
Oh, and I’ve plugged in a few USB devices, my camera being one, that have worked immediately with no probs.
Hi Duane,
I switched almost a year ago and have been using osx for personal work and windows for um work work. My pc is a thinkpad and the other is a macbook pro.
I very much prefer osx over windows but there’s several things about osx that annoy me. I was surprised to see drag and drop listed as a positive in your list. I find the opposite to be true. There’s been several occasions when I’ve tried to drag something in osx expecting it to work as it does in windows but it doesn’t.
Apple fans try to justify the application menu always being at the top of the screen but it’s really annoying when you’ve closed all program windows and there’s no indication that the program is still running with the exception of a tiny pointer in the dock…which in my case is usually hidden.
I don’t care much for the quasi intelligent maximise window widget either. Combine that with the ability to only resize windows from the bottom right corner, and the result is me swearing at the computer while I first drag the window to the top right then pull the bottom right to maximise the window.
Double clicking something always opens it. Except in osx. Double click the title bar and instead of the window being maximised, it’ll be minimised.
And don’t get me started on renaming files. I actually had to call someone to ask them how to do that. I couldn’t believe the context menu or even the finder menu doesn’t have a rename option.
Considering how important it is, I think Finder is one of the weakest areas of osx. Sometimes while I’m about to save a file, I’ll realise that I want to rename an existing file first before saving the new one. In windows, it’s a no brainer - right click the file, rename and then save the new file. Osx, not so simple. Can’t even cut a file and paste it elsewhere.
What annoys me most about osx isn’t even about osx, it’s all the negative apple ads. I know it sounds silly but somehow I feel the ‘I’m a Mac’ guy lives in my computer.
I haven’t been fanatic about any computer ever since the Amiga’s last few tortured years and I use windows and osx about the same amount of time each week so I feel I’m not biased. So when I see apple ads talking about windows freezing all the time, it’s very annoying because I find that I can run windows for weeks on end without shutting it down and yet I don’t experience these lockups. On the other hand, I just opened macbook pro and it wouldn’t come out of hibernation and when it did come alive after repeated pressing of the space bar, power button etc., it was a clean boot. Good thing I had saved my work.
I’ve never had any problems with any prepherals on the pc. Same as on osx.
It may sound like I don’t like osx. But I do. I just wish apple would lay off the negative ads. It’s a good enough os and doesn’t need the mud slinging. It would serve them and us better if they fixed finder instead.
Cheers!
This is not necessarily a plug, but a piece of software called Parallels is a very good and near-transparent way to run IE or any other windows software on your mac (if it’s an Intel Mac). I run IE, safari and Firefox in parallel while doing testing, and it works flawlessly. You can also drag and drop files between OS X and windows. Ever-loving harmony and peace.
http://www.parallels.com
> And don’t get me started on renaming files.
> I actually had to call someone to ask them how to do that.
Select the file or directory and press Enter (exactly the same as F2 in Windows), easy!
I agree with you on the software side. I love Mac OS and I can see how many of my friends and relatives stuck with Windows could benefit from the OS X expierence. But since I had nothing but troubles with my MacBook I just can’t recommend Macs because of Apple’s lousy hardware quality assurance (although AppleCare is quite good ;-)). Maybe I had bad luck but 4 defects within the first 8 months is just ridiculous. And it’s not just me, my sisters MacBook had troubles too …
Hi Ben,
>Select the file or directory and press Enter
>(exactly the same as F2 in Windows), easy!
I know how to do that NOW but imagine a new user trying to figure that out. There’s no entry for rename in the Edit menu or even the context menu.
Hey, you cant forget about the command line wonderfulness of Terminal.app! And the uber cool command line app “open”. You can tar something up, then do a open -a mail file.tgz and, poof, it opens mail.app w/ file.tgz as a attachment. I love the command line, and I really love the command line perks OSX has to offer. Also, I hear that Leopard has Terminal.app tab support. woo hoo!
Hi all,
Normally I don’t take the time to write any comments on sites because I’m too busy working but unfortunately there’s no work that can be done right now because ALL computers SUCK!!! If you don’t read this all the way down at least read the last paragraph…
Allow me to explain and blow off some steam…
In high school I used to go to the mall everyday (circa 1984) and dream about someday owning a Mac. Not being able to afford one I was forced to deal with a Commodore 64 (can you believe it)? Eventually I upgraded to a Commodore 128 and finally I got an Amiga! Little did I know back then that those were the best computing days of my life. Since then I began using PCs for work (due to Bill Gates’ monopoly on the market) so I decided to buy one myself. I’ve been from desktops to laptops and from Compaq to Gateway to HP (glorified Compaq) and each one has greatly succeeded in FAILING. Hardware and software has been a nightmare–don’t get me started on all the incarnations of Windows. And customer support should be called “lack there of.”
So here I am wasting valuable work time (but hopefully not because the masses will read this and revolt causing a major change in the industry–dream on). Anyway so after 4 laptops in 5 years (3 of which were bought in the last two years–a Gateway something or other, an HP zd8080us, a Gateway CX200X, and finally a HP dv6149us) I switched to a Macbook. I was totally going to be freed the chains that bound me to WINDOZE forever!!! At least that’s what I thought at the time. Believe it or not I had nothing but love for my Macbook with Intel processor. I even installed Parallels on it so that I could run all my XP programs that would cost me literally thousands to replace all in one shot (I’m a graphic designer for print and web so I use like 8 different programs–bought outright–that’s another story for another time…read the last paragraph). I spent $1,378 with tax for the Macbook plus $380 for the 2B memory upgrade plus $50 for a wired mouse plus $80 for a wireless mouse (once I found out it existed) plus $65 for a wireless keyboard plus $110 for one-on-one lessons to use my beautiful Macbook and learn how to stop being a sucker of XP, all totaling…$2,063. This doesn’t include the purchase of Parallels or full version of XP that was like another $300.
I’ve spent thousands on all these computers and spent another couple thousand on the “Savior” Macbook (they even dressed it up all in white to make it feel more celestial). Well kiddies believe it or not I wrote this on my HP dv6149us that is now running Windows Vista which I was forced to buy last week after I took my Macbook in for service. So Bill Gates gets to laugh in my face one more time. Because while I’m writing this dealing with Vista/HP driver issues and software re-installations for the 12th time (LITERALLY) at least this thing is up and running, although with same crappy types of problems I had with XP–you gotta love the windows registry!!! On a side note beware buying computer programs outright at full price (another scam). Most can only be installed one time on one computer so if you have to re-install you have to call customer support (if you can get through) and ask for a new activation code. SOME WILL FORCE YOU TO BUY A NEW LICENSE!!! Now consider that graphics/productivity programs go for hundreds and some very close to a thousand dollars for the full version. Shouldn’t you have the right to re-install it as many times as you want or even on several of your computers? Well that’s not the case with most. Photoshop CS2 so far is the only one I’ve encountered that lets you install on as many machines as you wish but only two computers can be activated at one time. So whatever happened to my Macbook? I just picked it up today and it turns out that the logic board was faulty as well as one of the new memory modules I purchased and I was charged $0 for repair. I was so excited that I bought the wireless keyboard and one-on-one lessons today! I got home and it turned on like a dream and shuts down fast too (less than 30 seconds for each). And the operating system is truly unmatched even by Vista (hybrid of XP with a total copy of Mac OSX). So why am I ALSO reinstalling the operating system on my Macbook for the third time since I started writing this????? Hopefully the one-on-one lessons will solve my issue. Yes, all computers suck but at least Macs have a Genius bar and if nothing else you have someone to scream at about all your woes!
THE END
I would not began to recommend Mac OS to friends.
Tengo ese modelo con leopard pero no tengo audio, tendran los codecs alguno de ustedes? Gracias
Leave a reply